Microsoft is making claims that their soon to be released Windows Live Essentials will be a better and direct competitor with Apple’s iLife suite. Before I tell you my opinion of what I have read about Live Essentials, I will first tell you about what the new product is slated to have.
First the public beta of the Windows Live Essentials 4 is likely to go public beta at the end of June. The expected name is probably going to be Windows Live Essentials 2011. The latest suite includes both software and services components designed to complement Windows (and especially Windows 7).
The latest Windows Live Essentials suite includes the following components:
Windows Live Mail (Web mail)
Windows Live Messenger (instant messaging)
Windows Live Photo Gallery
Windows Live Movie Maker
Windows Live Sync (Live Mesh plus the former Live Sync sync service)
Windows Live Writer (blogging tool)
Windows Live Family Safety (parental controls)
Bing Bar
Windows Live Mail – MS mail application versus the Apple Mail app. I am not sure if this is anything to get too excited about. I mean it is e-mail. People who really like to have complete and total control over their email are probably going to use something like Thunderbird or maybe Outlook.
Windows Live Messenger – MS answer to Apple iChat. Who cares? Most of use still using instant messaging are using an app that allows for multiple account types to be managed at once. Not locked into one type of messenger protocol. Sure it will include some fancy features and allow web cam conferences, but how many times have you really used that. Again, those that are serious about it are probably more likely to use the new version of Skype.
Windows Live Photo Gallery – This might be fine for the average home user needing to catalog their photos. iPhoto from Apple works fine for basic photo cataloging too, but again those that are really serious are more likely to use Adobe’s Lightroom. And unless MS does some real overhaul on the photo gallery, it is just about worthless.
Windows Live Movie Maker – Designed to go head to head with Apple’s iMovie, this had better be 100% better than it has been in previous versions. This is one app that I have never liked from MS and feel they could do much better with.
Windows Live Sync – No comment.
Windows Live Writer – Intended to compete with Apple’s iWeb. Basically it is Frontpage reinvented. After MS dropped the Frontpage product a few years back it hasn’t had an answer for it until now. For the person who has no idea about how to create a website or what it takes to update one, this might be the product they use. I am sure that you will be able to easily identify the sites created with this just like you could the Frontpage sites. You will probably be able to get a better looking website using a free service like Wordpress or Blogger than you could with either the Apple or the MS stuff.
Windows Live Family Safety – Parental controls and internet safety for the internet. Given the track record for Internet Explorer security, I wouldn’t put a lot of faith and trust in this.
Bing Bar – Really? Again, who cares? I don’t need another annoying tool bar or search bar app thrown at me.
So what’s the big deal about MS Windows Essentials? MS claims it will appeal to customers more because it is free. Apple iLife cost $79. Apple iLife come on all new macs for free. You only have to pay the $79 if you don’t already have it or decide to upgrade to the new versions when they are released. You also have to pay an annual fee for the MobileMe sync services with Apple, but there are rumors that Apple may be making that a free service sometime soon.
Which is better? Unless MS has made some real improvements and user enhancements to their listed products, I would still prefer to use the iLife apps over MS any day. I iLife apps are very easy to work with and make the difficult tasks easy to manage. Plus MS does not have an answer at this time to Apple’s GarageBand.